I recently became a man-at-arms to a local knight and the other day we were talking about how I can get my White Scarf. After a little bit of talking, he came up with an unusual idea. Or at least one that struck me as unusual. He said that I shouldn't worry about trying to get my White Scarf for now. Instead, I should go for a Laurel in fencing. His reasoning was that if I go that route, I'll get my White Scarf along the way.
Of course, that's going to mean a lot of work on my part. I'd like to think that I'm within a year or two of being able to earn my scarf, but I haven't even begun on the road to a Laurel. Or rather, I abandoned that road 10 years ago. So now I have to look back on where I was then and decide if I want to return to those abandoned projects (comparing SCA blades to ones found in period and an attempt to make sense of Williams' Pallas Armata) or if I want to try something new. And if I go with something new, what should it be?
It would almost have to be studying one of the masters. At least if I truly want to get my Laurel for "fencing." It seems to me that just about anything else would fall under some other category and I'd wind up as a Laurel who fences, rather than a fencing Laurel. Not that that would be such a bad thing, but it's not what I want. I want to be a true fencing master, not a blade master or a master smith or any other type of master.
But I do realize that my blinders might be on and that there might be another route that would make me a fencing master, instead of just a master who fences, but I can't see it. What do you guys think? Is there another route that would get me where I'm going?
How does fencing fit as a "Laurel-able" skill set? As a martial activity it is destructive. Art, which is what a Laurel is for, is creative, not destructive. Do you take the view that it is a performance, like dance? If so, to extend the analogy, there is a difference in dance between getting your feet in the right place at the right time and dancing beautifully. It is an aesthetic quality that creates art. Is such an "aesthetic leap" possible in fencing? Of course, this is only in reference to fencing done according to period models rather than fencing done in a modern, or purely "sport" mode.
ReplyDeleteJuana Isabella
West
I hope you don't mind, but I'm going to use a full-fledged post to answer this one.
ReplyDelete